The American League and National League rosters for next Tuesday’s All-Star Game were announced yesterday but, as has become customary in recent years, there is one spot left in each league for fans to vote on who they think deserve it. There are five candidates for each league’s Final Vote, and here is who I think should make the cut.
- OF Andrew Benintendi, Red Sox
- OF Eddie Rosario, Twins
- SS Jean Segura, Mariners
- SS Andrelton Simmons, Angels
- OF Giancarlo Stanton, Yankees
Given the size of their teams’ fan bases, I think either Benintendi or Stanton will win the vote, probably Stanton, but I don’t think either of them deserves it. My vote goes to Rosario, but playing for the Twins will hurt his case.
- 1B Jesus Aguilar, Brewers
- 1B Brandon Belt, Giants
- 3B Matt Carpenter, Cardinals
- 1B Max Muncy, Dodgers
- SS Trea Turner, Nationals
This is a tough call. I think Muncy will get a lot of votes because he’s a bit of a feel-good story, hitting 20 home runs already after not playing at all last season and having just 215 at-bats in Major League Baseball prior to this season. But he’s not the best candidate in my opinion. My vote goes to Aguilar, who has a couple more home runs and a batting average that is more than 30 points higher than Muncy’s. Out of the 10 players in the Final Vote between the two leagues, I think Aguilar is the one who most deserves to be in the game.